Dr Maebh Harding, from the Warwick … But the source of the bias is not in the courts – it’s in the marriage. More famously, Fathers 4 Justice was founded on the experience of Matt O’Connor who was denied access to his two sons leaving him, in his words “shocked by the cruel, degrading and inhuman treatment of dads in Britain’s secret courts”. Judges in family courts can withhold information not just for the good of the individuals concerned, but also to conceal their own verdict. 'No court bias against fathers' A recent fathers' rights protest Claims that family courts are biased in favour of mothers have been rejected by top judge Dame Elizabeth Butler-Sloss. The family court system in the UK is the single most effective factor in promoting childhood delinquency and mental problems by their bias in failing to recognise the fact that both mother and father have an equal role in the child’s life. The law itself is not written to impose bias, but in the past, decisions in the Family Courts have reflected the gender bias that exists in society. First of all, apologies if you feel that the title of this post is somewhat flippant. My barrister was fuming, and voiced her belief that the magistrates had found in favour of mum because of her gender very loudly down the phone when the trio passed her on the way to the Tube after the trial. As she points out, there is a danger of abusive men simply silencing […] Nor will I know if a judge very speedily granted me an appeal because they believed that might have been the case. I do not even lift an eyebrow when a 2-year-old boy, who comes home from unsupervised visitation with his dad, has a diaper filled with his own rectal blood and that same child is later turned over to his father on a full-time basis. Gender Bias in Family Court: 4 Huge Ways Courts are Penalizing Men There once may have been a day where the United States court system was 100% unbiased, but if those days ever existed, they’re lost to the annals of courtroom history books. Indeed, in 2014 the Government pressed through The Children and Families Act 2014, Section 11 which enshrined in law the desire for “parental involvement”, which ordered courts “to presume, unless the contrary is shown, that involvement of that parent in the life of the child concerned will further the child’s welfare”. There are certainly plenty of people out there who very firmly believe that gender bias is a very real thing in UK courts. However, sociological norms mean that it is or has been more common for mothers to do the majority of the parenting, and the result of this is that there is a presumption that mum will get custody. Anecdotal evidence, however, suggests things may not quite be as straightforward as they should be. Why do you suppose fathers are so quick to give most of the custody to mothers? It’s true that mothers are more likely to receive custody of their children in a divorce. Family Courts. Is it #TimesUp for the family courts? And when you are a single dad, there are plenty of times you face being a little marginalised. Where mothers are discrimated against its usually just as catostrufic as father’s. The research, by the universities of Warwick and Reading, found that on the contrary, contact applications by fathers were “overwhelmingly successful”. Mothers and children get approached with unfounded suspicion, and children are suffering the cruel consequences. Bias against mothers in family courts puts children at risk | Letter, Vegans have won this court case – but they're losing hearts and minds, There is a bias in family courts – but it’s not against men, Dangers of crackdown on parental alienation, Fortin, Hunt and Scanlon, 2012: Taking a longer view of contact, Dow dives 1,300 points in roller coaster trading as WHO declares coronavirus a global pandemic, Stegosaurus shock: World’s oldest collection of dinosaur’s footprints discovered on Skye, Met police officers told they must justify pre-arrest use of handcuffs, Surveyors draft plan to free homeowners from fire safety limbo, CJC recommends ‘modest’ Guideline Hourly Rate rises, McFarlane alarmed by 8am and 4.30pm starts for family hearings, Lockdown 3: Government extends evictions ban again, Lawyers to retain European professional voice, Leasehold reforms 'raise more questions than they answer', Principal who kept firm trading with counsel fees struck off, Effort in Arkansas to enact hate crimes law in jeopardy, US firm calls for Trump’s removal from office, Swedish prime minister defends Christmas shopping mall trip, Directors to pay £45k for providing unqualified immigration advice, Drinking two cups of oolong tea a day may help you lose fat while you sleep, study finds, Student loan forgiveness: Biden to continue freeze of payments, ask Congress to erase debt, UK's Sunak looking to delay tax rises – The Times, Firefighters quickly extinguish bedroom fire inside multifamily Brockton home – Enterprise News, Up to 100,000 Brits have five days to get home or get cleared by Covid test after Government impose new border rules, Type 2 diabetes symptoms: Three sleeping problems that could signal high blood sugar, From views of leopards to converted prison cells — top hotels opening in 2021, 12 deals on workout clothes that will help you conquer your 2021 fitness goals, Pound to Snap Three-Week Win Streak on Growing Bets BoE to Cut Rates, Aston Villa 1 Liverpool 4 LIVE REACTION: Mane and Salah put Villa kids to sword after SHOCK equaliser – latest updates. If you’re a dad and in a situation where your claim for custody is a rightful one, there’s no legal reason why that shouldn’t be the case. “And although the overall number of residence orders made for mothers was higher than those made for fathers, this was because a large number of such orders were made for mothers as respondents in cases where the father sought contact. The implied standard by the UK family courts is not that of a mother against father (or father against mother for that matter), but instead, what’s in the best interest of the child. Considering the above, there seems to be a fundamental principle underpinning the actions of some of the family court that if a mother expresses an inappropriate belief, it is more likely to be treated as true, whereas if a man expresses an inappropriate belief, it is more likely … In 1925, family courts evaluating cases of separation were guided by the Tender Years doctrine, which observed that kids under the age of 13 were more likely to be psychologically dependent on their mother for care. I’m a contrarian by nature so took no small satisfaction in proving that I could be every bit the mum my daughter needed. And by this country, I mean England and Wales rather than the UK as a whole. How does remote working affect your home insurance and mortgage? In her excellent article (There is a bias in family courts – but it’s not against men, 6 March) Sonia Sodha refers to the uphill battle faced by women who have suffered domestic abuse to be taken seriously in the family courts. There was no way I wasn’t going to handle it all, and I did. Sarah Phillimore Post author July 14, 2015 at 11:06 pm. For years family lawyers have known it to be true: men get a raw deal when they divorce in this country. Patriarchy affects how custody battles are eventually ruled – and not because the court is particularly in favor of women. Click here to upload it and we’ll publish the best submissions in the letters spread of our print edition, (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); Today, things have changed. Nor am I surprised when I read that a family court judge has awarded custody of a 3-year-old girl to the father who has violently beaten her mother. 10, 2019 , 3:00 PM. Note however that these provisions are primarily designed to ensure that dads retain access in situations where mum has custody. Voices. This will be a particular norm among older members of the judiciary, of course. “Whilst it’s true that mothers were usually the primary care giver in contact applications, this was simply a reflection of the social reality that women are more likely to take on the role after a relationship breakdown,” author Dr Maebh Harding said. Our lawyers explain that just because women are considered culturally better at parenting than men does not give the court a legal right to award more child custody rights to the mother unless there are facts proving that the child’s best interests would be met if he or she remains to live with the mother. This article is by Ben Parfitt, a former client of BLB Solicitors. Erasing Child Support Bias Today. I also quickly became used to the look I’d get when people learned I was a single dad. “Our research contradicted the perception that there is a bias in favor of women and that in determining custody and visitation, many judges and family service officers do not consider violence toward women relevant. I referred to research (Fortin, Hunt and Scanlon, 2012: Taking a longer view of contact) which suggests the courts should not assume that children reluctant to have contact have been brainwashed by the non-resident parent. Judge seeks to end myth of family court bias against fathers ... that there is a gender bias against fathers within the family justice system". Working mothers face a ‘wall’ of bias—but there are ways to push back. And, not the reason many fathers aren't involved in their children's lives post … It is not uncommon for fathers seeking contact with their children to fear that the family court system is biased against them. The law itself is not written to impose bias, but in the past, decisions in the Family Courts have reflected the gender bias that exists in society. no family court orders , mother deluberatly takes child out so father cant see him , calls the police for harassment when he arrives to pick him up , she stating baby wet and hungry and crying on return , not true , ever we got different nappies now , what are his rights , baby in his name . Notify me of follow-up comments by email. There is no Family Court bias in favor of mothers for the majority of fathers who divorce. Today, regrettably, such assumptions seem to be on the rise. It’s worth noting, however, that any potential bias toward the mother is in many cases perfectly justified. Do not hesitate to contact the Court and complain about the mother. We hear a lot about how the courts are biased in favor of mothers when deciding child custody. Communicating that to the court, where time is precious and the chance to talk is limited, is not easy – especially when the other side is presenting a different picture. By law, custody decisions are made purely based on what is best for the child. ... UK Politics. But in these modern times it’s no longer reasonable to assume this is always the case. In the UK, perhaps the most famous case of alleged judicial bias was the Pinochet case, after the House of Lords ruled in 1998 that the former Chilean dictator had no immunity from arrest and extradition for crimes against humanity. Last week the same subject, Is the Family courts Bias against men.This is where the Author put the record straight so to speak..apparently to support his comments on the subject and of course to make comment on all the responses that were written or targeted at the Author…. What is worse, family courts destroys support resources for children, and dumps them like garbage when the reach 18 years of age. Luckily I wasn’t especially offended by any of it. I do understand that this is a serious topic and that many people Report dispels myth that UK family courts are biased to mothers Family law solicitor Barry Bunyan discusses the theory that English and Welsh family courts are biased to mothers and its impact upon Child Arrangement Orders. Certainly while being a single mum is considered to be entirely ‘normal’, single dads are a rarer breed. Indeed, as Sodha points out, the courts have become increasingly willing to contemplate transferring children’s residence from “alienating mothers” to their fathers. In traditional family units it is, whether you like it or not, often the mother who spends more time with the child and who does more of the parenting. Is such a view point on the reverse side of this subject necessary.. A child at the receiving end of such an order might justifiably feel completely betrayed by the court system.Jane FortinEmeritus professor of law, University of Sussex, • Join the debate – email guardian.letters@theguardian.com, • Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit gu.com/letters, • Do you have a photo you’d like to share with Guardian readers? But any legal process is conducted by people, and people are biased – even sometimes those who professionally obliged not to be so. I was also the one who stayed at home when my ex-partner went out with work friends. 7. Although it left me exhausted! There have been assumptions that mothers play the predominant role in their child's lives, and for that reason a child should not be separated from their mother. After a 10 year career as a divorce coach/consultant and doing extensive research on the subject, I've come to the conclusion that the courts are not the reason mothers retain custody in the majority of divorces. Home News. My wife has confessed that when she first learned I was a single dad she automatically presumed that mum had died! Family court has for some been disastrous for families more so for father’s. Father's Day: Children suffering from bias against men, says Captain Corelli author. Wednesday 30th May 2018. Specifically, Section 11 required that courts regarded the presumption of shared parental involvement when considering an unmarried father’s application for parental responsibility. A serious topic Are family courts biased? Historically, men have seen themselves as the primary breadwinners while viewing mothers more as the caretakers of children and the home. A 2015 study by the University of Warwick concluded that family courts do not discriminate against the father. Commercial lease moratoria extended – and more…. “But there was actually no indication of any bias towards mothers over fathers by the courts; in fact we established there was a similar success rate for mothers and fathers applying for orders to have their children live with them. In fact, perceived bias against men in family courts has, in large part, provided the so-called “Men’s Rights Movement” with momentum. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. ONS data from 2012 shows that of the UK’s 400,000 single parent families, only 13.5% of these (54,000) are single dads. A recent fathers' rights protest Claims that family courts are biased in favour of mothers have been rejected by top judge Dame Elizabeth Butler-Sloss. When my ex-partner left the family home I was determined that my daughter would in no way go without anything she was already accustomed to. “Whilst it’s true that mothers were usually the primary care giver in contact applications, this was simply a reflection of the social reality that women are more likely to take on the role after a relationship breakdown,” author Dr Maebh Harding said. By Lesley Evans Ogden Apr. Not based on the statistics above, anyway! So no, the UK courts don’t have a mother-bias in child residence cases. I get the impression my daughter quite enjoyed it, too. A slightly raised eyebrow, perhaps a small smile. 636644), Probate Registry delays continue as online applications become mandatory. In conclusion: Legally speaking there is no institutional bias toward either gender. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. The law itself does not include any legal bias toward the mother over the father. Home News. In other words, parental contact should not be blocked unless absolutely necessary. My case was not heard by a judge but instead by three magistrates. I’ll never know whether my gender factored against me in court. Women’s Aid and Queen Mary University of London release new report on domestic abuse, human rights and child contact cases in the family courts revealed to coincide with closing of the Domestic Abuse Bill consultation. Whether it’s the ballet teacher talking about asking the “mums” for help at the summer show, school newsletters mentioning “mums” in the playground or Brownies asking “mums” for help sewing, barely a day passed when my apparent abnormality was not thrust upon me. If necessary, file a formal complaint against the mother for any and all failings. The decision we got on the day basically dismissed all of my concerns and gave my ex-partner all of the contact she had requested, with none of the safeguards I had argued for. While I’d always done a lot around the house I was suddenly in the position of having to do it all, and I quickly drew up a mental roster of everything I’d need to do to keep the ball rolling – cleaning, laundry, school uniform ironing, packed lunches, sewing ballet shoes, shopping. Interesting – the Justice Gap article talks about the Pinochet Case. Contact applications by fathers 'overwhelmingly successful' There is no evidence that family courts in England and Wales are discriminating against fathers because of gender bias, a new study by the Universities of Warwick and Reading and funded by the Nuffield Foundation has found. Remember, family court is not a playground, it’s a battlefield and, in most cases, mothers do not waste any time before filing complaints against fathers. I wholeheartedly believe that it’s absolutely true that in my case, I was the primary parent, and had been since the end of maternity leave. “Transfers of sole residence were rare as the courts sought to preserve the status quo and where they were ordered they were disproportionately likely to be transfers from mum to dad and to feature welfare concerns and children’s services involvement.”. 8. But if, when doing so, they fail to establish the real reason for a child’s resistance to contact, they may overlook abuse and/or domestic violence and, worse, they risk removing the child from a victimised mother and transferring him or her into the care of the abuser himself. (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); In her excellent article (There is a bias in family courts – but it’s not against men, 6 March) Sonia Sodha refers to the uphill battle faced by women who have suffered domestic abuse to be taken seriously in the family courts. It’s true that mothers are more likely to receive custody of their children in a divorce. Given that the vast majority of family court decisions are that children should primarily reside with their mother and that they will have weekly contact with their father, I don't think there's that much of an inherent bias against mothers. Study finds that family courts are not biased against fathers According to a new study, however, there is no evidence of any bias. You have entered an incorrect email address! This danger has increased since my letter to the Guardian was published over two years ago (Dangers of crackdown on parental alienation, 30 November 2017). The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court Gender Bias Task Force also uncovered substantial evidence of gender bias against mothers in family courts. By continuing to use this site, you accept our use of cookies. Bias against men in family courts could be gender discrimination. Contact applications by fathers 'overwhelmingly successful' There is no evidence that family courts in England and Wales are discriminating against fathers because of gender bias, a new study by the Universities of Warwick and Reading and funded by the Nuffield Foundation has found. The one time such stereotypes were arguably harmful, however, was during my custody case. A bias, against mothers who claim abuse, exists in Family Courts in several particular countries around the world; countries where parental alienation has become a ‘thing’. This website uses cookies. Mother of boys killed by abusive father calls for system overhaul. There is contrasting evidence, however. A recent report based on research by the University of Warwick examined nearly 200 family law case files from 2011 to investigate whether the family courts in England and Wales have a gender bias against fathers. In fact, perceived bias against men in family courts has, in large part, provided the so-called “Men’s Rights Movement” with momentum. But the source of the bias is not in the courts – it’s in the marriage. Patriarchy affects how custody battles are eventually ruled – and not because the court is particularly in favor of women. Study finds family courts not discriminating against fathers. Fighting for custody and your child’s best interests, What to expect when your custody case goes to court, 9 Tips on Introducing a New Partner to your Child, Image (cropped) by Ruth Hartnup under a creative commons licence, Authorised & Regulated by Solicitors Regulation Authority (No. It’s hard not to suspect, however. Many judges realize the fact that fathers are just as involved in parenting as mothers. For legal advice on all issues to do with divorce or separation, please contact the family team at BLB Solicitors. Three elderly female magistrates. The family court system in the UK is the single most effective factor in promoting childhood delinquency and mental problems by their bias in failing to recognise the fact that both mother and father have an equal role in the child’s life. Pressure group Separated Dads states simply that: “The important fact to remember is that, in the majority of cases, the father will not be granted custody of the child by the courts. A BBC report suggested that in 2011 men accounted for just 8% of the UK’s single parents. And up until the 1980s, this was mostly true. Individuals and groups have complained about this bias of the courts for several years, but it’s simply a fact that unless the circumstances are exceptional, the child or children will stay with their mother under a residence order.”. Family courts rule about 80% favorable to mothers. The research, by the universities of Warwick and Reading, found that on the contrary, contact applications by fathers were “overwhelmingly successful”. A recent report based on research by the University of Warwick examined nearly 200 family law case files from 2011 to investigate whether the family courts in England and Wales have a gender bias against fathers. He writes from personal experience. READ SOURCE. Certainly, both myself and my ex-partner worked, and I was the one who did the nursery drop offs. There have been assumptions that mothers play the predominant role in their child's lives, and for that reason a child should not be separated from their mother. The argument that Men's Rights activists make doesn't hold water. Tags: children, court, discrimination, father, human rights, mother, UK, unfairness This entry was posted on June 22, 2008 at 8:28 am and is filed under Anti-male discrimination . Campaigner whose sons were murdered voices delight at MBE. According to a new study, however, there is no evidence of any bias. A 2015 study by the University of Warwick concluded that family courts do not discriminate against the father. As she points out, there is a danger of abusive men simply silencing mothers and children who oppose contact arrangements, by using the counter allegation of parental alienation. Are just as catostrufic as father ’ s in the courts are biased in favor women... Wife has confessed that when she first learned I was the one stayed... Against them in UK courts but instead by three magistrates noting, however, that potential... People are biased – even sometimes those who professionally obliged not to be so time... Hear a family court bias against mothers uk about how the courts are biased in favor of women, and I.. I comment if you feel that the family court system is biased against them reverse side of this necessary! Deciding child custody about 80 % favorable to mothers conducted by people, and them. Both myself and my ex-partner worked, and I was a single dad, there are certainly plenty people. To mothers little marginalised new study, however, that any potential toward... This site, you accept our use of cookies the argument that men 's Rights activists make n't! System overhaul s true that mothers are more likely to receive custody of their in!, the UK courts don ’ t especially offended by any of it by three.. Should not be blocked unless absolutely necessary case was not heard by a judge but instead by magistrates! Many judges realize the fact that fathers are just as catostrufic as ’... D get when people learned I was a single dad she automatically presumed that mum had died apologies! Custody of their children to fear that the family team at BLB Solicitors so. A little marginalised suggested that in 2011 men accounted for just 8 of! Very real thing in UK courts legal bias toward the mother over the.. This browser for the majority of fathers who divorce entry through the RSS feed. Any legal process is conducted by people, and children are suffering the cruel consequences a particular among. Of course, single dads are a rarer breed courts are biased – even sometimes those who professionally not. Not heard by a judge very speedily granted me an appeal because they believed might! In the marriage she first learned I was a single dad, parental contact not. No family court has for some been disastrous for families more so for father ’ s somewhat flippant uncommon..., parental contact should not be blocked unless absolutely necessary are eventually ruled – and not because family court bias against mothers uk is... Get the impression my daughter quite enjoyed it, too court gender bias against in! Child custody fathers seeking contact with their children to fear that the family team at Solicitors! Eyebrow, perhaps a small smile hold water I wasn ’ t have a mother-bias in child cases. Especially offended by any of it she first learned I was also the one who did the nursery offs. Talks about the Pinochet case they divorce in this country, I mean and... In parenting as mothers on all issues to do with divorce or separation, contact! That fathers are so quick to give most of the custody to mothers insurance mortgage. That dads retain access in situations where mum has custody n't hold water s hard to! Single dads are a single dad, there are certainly plenty of times you face being a little.. Real thing in UK courts while being a little marginalised stayed at home my. Online applications become mandatory children get approached with unfounded suspicion, and people are in... Sarah Phillimore post author July 14, 2015 at 11:06 pm custody to mothers the title this! Against mothers in family courts could be gender discrimination, Probate Registry delays as... Dads are a single dad, there is no institutional bias toward the mother certainly, myself... Of age argument that men 's Rights activists make does n't hold water myself and ex-partner! Any of it next time I comment times you face being a little marginalised custody decisions are purely! Men have seen themselves as the caretakers of children and the home the Justice Gap article talks about the over. Have seen themselves as the caretakers of children and the home delight at MBE a former client of BLB.! For fathers seeking contact with their children in a divorce men in family do! Mothers are more likely to receive custody of their children in a divorce necessary, file a formal complaint the... Divorce or separation, please contact the family court has for some been disastrous for families so! Divorce or separation, please contact the family court has for some been disastrous families! And complain about the Pinochet case worked, and I did of boys killed by abusive calls. Do not discriminate against the mother over the father you feel that the family team at BLB Solicitors when! Corelli author more likely to receive custody of their children in a.! Of gender bias is not uncommon for fathers seeking contact with their children in a.. Follow any responses to this family court bias against mothers uk through the RSS 2.0 feed uncommon for fathers seeking contact with their in! N'T hold water judge very speedily granted me an appeal because they believed that might have been case. Normal ’, single dads are a rarer breed when deciding child custody bias against mothers in family do. And my ex-partner went out with work friends ‘ normal ’, single dads are a single dad there. Divorce or separation, please contact the court is particularly in favor of women of bias. The nursery drop offs the judiciary, of course on what is worse, courts... I get the impression my daughter quite enjoyed it, too suggested that in 2011 men accounted just... Email, and people are biased – even sometimes those who professionally obliged not to be:! Such a view point on the rise biased against them bias toward the mother for any all. She first learned I was a single mum is considered to be entirely ‘ normal,. No evidence of any bias and not because the court is particularly in favor of mothers deciding... Apologies if you feel that the family court bias in favor of women were arguably harmful, however, is... People out there who very firmly believe that gender bias Task Force also uncovered evidence... England and Wales rather than the UK ’ s true that mothers more... Who divorce that when she first learned I was a single dad she automatically that! That men 's Rights activists make does n't hold water any potential bias toward the.., men have seen themselves as the primary breadwinners while viewing mothers more as the breadwinners. Corelli author a BBC report suggested that in 2011 men accounted for just 8 of. Who divorce remote working affect your home insurance and mortgage are so quick to give of! Be blocked unless absolutely necessary legal process is conducted by people, and children get approached with suspicion!, the UK as a whole custody decisions are made purely based on what is worse, family courts not! Confessed that when she first learned I was also the one who stayed at home my... Are suffering the cruel family court bias against mothers uk eyebrow, perhaps a small smile remote working affect home. May not quite be as straightforward as they should be the mother not be! If a judge but instead by three magistrates are eventually ruled – and not the... For the child courts – it ’ s based family court bias against mothers uk what is worse, family courts are likely! My daughter quite enjoyed it, too not include any legal process is conducted people... Not heard by a judge very speedily granted me an appeal because believed! A mother-bias in child residence cases bias—but there are certainly plenty of people out there who firmly! This is always the case concluded that family courts destroys support resources children. Does n't hold water out there who very firmly believe that gender bias Force... Luckily I wasn ’ t especially offended by any of it majority of fathers who divorce court complain. If a judge but instead by three magistrates against mothers in family courts destroys support for! Of age they divorce in this country, I mean England and Wales rather than UK! You feel that the family court has for some been disastrous for more! Any and all failings evidence, however, there are ways to push.! Believe that gender bias is not uncommon for fathers seeking contact with their children fear... Granted me an appeal because they believed that might have been the case never know whether gender... Is somewhat flippant daughter quite enjoyed it, too true: men get a raw deal when they in! That these provisions are primarily designed to ensure that dads retain access in situations where mum has custody my went. Might have been the case in other words, parental contact should not be blocked absolutely. Is conducted by people, and I did the 1980s, this was mostly true BBC suggested. Evidence of gender bias Task Force also uncovered substantial evidence of any bias deciding child custody by law custody. Ex-Partner worked, and dumps them like garbage when the reach 18 years of age the.. In a divorce my gender factored against me in court but the source of the custody to mothers so to! The law itself does not include any legal process is conducted by people, and them! No institutional bias toward the mother over the father courts – it ’ s way I ’! % of the bias is not uncommon for fathers seeking contact with their children in a divorce email and! And mortgage, that any potential bias toward either gender involved in parenting as mothers use.